By Montague Gammon III

One of opera’s best known works, “Pagliacci,” comes to the stage of the Harrison Opera House full of “high octane, high drama, high energy,” to quote Virginia Opera’s Artistic Director and “Pagliacci” conductor, Adam Turner.

This famous tragedy of a heartbroken clown who wallows in a Marianas Trench of gorgeously tuneful tenor self pity, before a romantic triangle develops a weapons grade sharp apex, opens the Opera’s season November 6 and 8 in Norfolk, with additional performances in Richmond and Fairfax later in the month.

The general plot of jealous husband/lover/suitor turned violent, while hardly unique in the art form, is one which a sizable fraction of the general population associates with this particular work. Perhaps that’s because this husband’s self referential aria “Vesti la giubba,” about a clown who must hide his broken heart, is a favorite recital (and Youtube) showpiece.

Sidelight: “Pagliacci,” premiered in 1892, was the first opera recorded in full (1907) and the first complete opera put on film with sound (1931).

A spoiler summary: In an itinerant troupe of players who perform in clown makeup, leading man Canio is married to beautiful Nedda, after whom both company member Tonio and townsperson Silvio lust. Nedda and Silvio are in love and planning to elope, an arrangement that isn’t going to work out once Tonio, recently rebuffed by Nedda and feeling vengeful, gets wind of their extra-marital activities and partnership plans. Tragedy lurks, and eventually puts in a grandly climactic appearance.

This is set to what Turner calls “some of the greatest tunes in all of opera.”

The plot of the troupe’s own traveling show has a similar but make-believe triangle. Nedda plays Colombina, wife of Pagliaccio, the character whom Canio plays, and Columbina has a lover named Arlecchio, played by company member Beppe.

This mirroring makes “Pagliacci” a play-within-a-play, or rather, within an opera.Critical and promotional commentary about life mimicking art being interspersed with art mimicking life often accompanies “Pagliacci,” but there’s a little known twist involved, which Turner revealed in our phone conversation.

“Pagliacci” is possibly based on a real 19th Century incident in which an actor murdered his wife on stage, in front of an audience, according to Turner’s research. That was the claim of composer and librettist Ruggero Leoncavallo, who wrote an article around the turn of the last century, claiming that his father, a judge, had presided over that case and so provided the seed of Leoncavallo’s opera.

(Lawsuits and countersuits accused Leoncavallo of stealing his plot, so perhaps he was trying to counter accusations of plagiarism, but it’s fun to find another layer of reality underpinning the show.)

Soprano Sarah Tucker sings her first Nedda; Virginia Opera audiences heard her as Freia in “Das Rheingold” five years ago, and more recently as Michaëla in “Carmen,” Turner remembered, where she was paired with tenor Zach Borishevsky who played the murderous Don Jose.

Now Borichevsky plays Canio, yet another partner whose possessiveness turns deadly. Like Tucker and others in this cast, he comes to Virginia trailing high praise from all over the country.

Opera West’s reviewer said that Tucker had “one of the loveliest soprano voices I’ve heard in years,” and the VaOpera website quotes an evaluation of Borishevsky as being “equipped with a flexible, bright voice that already has made him one of the most sought-after singers of his generation.”

The role of the scheming Tonio goes to baritone Kidon Choi, of whom Turner said “He’s been on my radar for a few years. I’ve tried to get him for several years but his schedule is so full doing big house debuts.” (San Diego Opera and Opera San Jose heard Choi do Tonio last season.)

Bass Baritone Hunter Enoch, who takes on the role of Nedda’s non-theatrical lover Silvio, was a Virginia Opera Emerging Artist “a decade ago,” Turner said. Enoch has gone on to sing “principal roles all over the country,” and during the pandemic moved with wife (and now small children) to Hampton Roads. He teaches at the Governor’s School, and gives private voice lessons “When he’s not on the road performing,” Turner added. Turner wooed Enoch away from singing “big dramatic baritone roles,” to get “a more hefty instrument in this role…a more full-throated sound.”

Carlos Ahrens, a tenor and first year emerging artist, plays Beppe, who in turn plays Arlecchino, Columbina’s stage (but not “real”) lover. Ahrens resume already includes two seasons of roles at the important Glimmerglass Festival, Turner mentioned, while talking about the competitiveness of VA Opera’s Emerging Artist program. Typically there are some 700 applicants; only 6-10 make the cut each year. (That means at best about 1.4% of applicants are accepted.)

VaOpera favorite Kyle Lang is directing. He’s been turning out memorable shows here since he helmed “Boheme” eleven years ago.

“The last time we did [‘Pagliacci”] was 10 years ago,” Turner said. “we paired it with a short Kurt Weill piece [“The Seven Deadly Sins”]. “This time we really just wanted to focus on this piece. We did it back in the 90’s as a stand alone piece. It’s so over the top that it’s very satisfying by itself.” (Turner was chuckling as he made that last remark.)

“I love the score,” he continued. “I think it’s probably one of the most exciting scores…You will leave the opera house feeling like you’ve had a full meal. You get it all in this piece…a short opera but really big in intensity [like] something that is ripped from a tabloid magazine.” 

To staunch opera fans, Turner said this: “it’s an opportunity to reconnect with the opera that made you fall in love with opera and see the newest generation of young singers put their stamp on these roles that you think you know. You’ve heard it all before but you have not heard it quite like this.”

To folks considering their first, or almost first, opera attendance he promised, “This is iconic…It’s spawned so many popular culture references and advertisements and popular songs over decades. If you’ve never been to an opera because you’ve been afraid of the language or the length this is the one that will burst all of those stereotypes and the myths that opera isn’t for you. This is the one that will get you.”

 

WANT TO GO?

“Pagliacci”

Score and lyrics by Ruggero Leoncavallo
Sung in Italian with English captions
Conducted by Adam Turner
Directed by Kyle Lang
Scenic Design by Steven C. Kemp

The orchestra for this production is provided by the Virginia Symphony Orchestra.

Approximate Runtime: 90 minutes with no intermission

7:30 p.m., Fri., Nov. 6

2:30 p.m., Sun.,Nov 8

Harrison Opera House, 160 West Virginia Beach Blvd, at Llewellyn Ave.

https://vaopera.org

866-673-7282